When Over-Qualified Workers Struggles To Find A Job

July 10, 2022

Intuitively, it seems employers would want to hire the most skilled and experienced candidates. But that’s not always the reality.

When Emily wanted to move into her dream career, she assumed her best option was to apply for an entry-level admin position and work her way up. There was a vacancy at a major entertainment company in London; her five years working at other multinational corporations meant she fulfilled every requirement of the job spec.

The tactic seemed to work: the company’s hiring team contacted Emily within days. But there was good and bad news. “They said I had a very impressive CV and was an outstanding candidate,” she explains. “But in the interview, they told me I was over-qualified: that I’d quickly end up bored in a job that was beneath my experience.”

As a compromise, the company promised Emily a new role. Ultimately, however, the position fell through. Not only did it leave Emily stuck in a role she wanted to quit, but also in a Catch-22; she was too skilled for an entry-level position in her target career, but not skilled enough to apply for a vacancy that matched her current job title.

The whole process left Emily, who is using one name for job-security reasons, frustrated. “I’d rather have just been given the original role as advertised”.

“Good isn’t necessarily good”
As workers’ careers progress, they typically ascend into more senior roles, gradually making their way towards management or executive positions. However, the higher employees go, the fewer the alternative jobs.

“They move towards the peak of a pyramid,” explains Terry Greer-King, vice-president of EMEA at cybersecurity firm SonicWall, based in London. “As they gain greater experience, there’s less breadth in terms of opportunities: trying something different would require scaling back down the pyramid.”

Applying for positions apparently ‘below’ current career level could be a red flag.
In some instances, employees want to take a step back to move forwards. This could be for a career change, such as in Emily’s case, or because an experienced worker, struggling to climb the next rung of the ladder, opts for a lateral or downwards move to make a longer-term gain. Personal circumstances can also play a factor: a relocation or a return to work following a career gap may force a worker to downgrade their job title.

Yet while these circumstances might feel like good reasons to candidates, recruiters can see workers applying for positions apparently ‘below’ their current career level as a red flag. For Greer-King, a CV of an overly-experienced candidate is like one indicating job-hopping or no movement at all – it's cause for suspicion.

“In hiring, you have to act paranoid,” he says. “If someone is coming down a level or two, and they've likely already achieved what the role offers, then you have to ask questions about their motivation.”

While a handful of candidates might manage to successfully explain their motives and convince companies they really want to take that step down, others may suffer from recruiters’ fears that a lower role will leave them unsatisfied. The concern is that the over-qualified worker will soon find themselves unchallenged, bored and itching for their next move.

“When someone joins a company, it could take three months to a year to get them fully productive,” explains Greer-King. “Even if someone is overly skilled for the role, they can’t just turn up and do the job: they need to understand the culture, processes and technology. So, investing so much time in someone, only for them to leave six months later, isn’t the wisest hiring choice.”

Workers in senior roles in industries where the corporate ladder is well established, like management consulting, can be particularly vulnerable to the perils of being over-qualified. “Someone might have deep expertise in one field and apply for a job in another, only to be informed by the recruiting team they should apply for a higher role,” says Davis Nguyen, founder of My Consulting Offer, based in Georgia, US. “But if the firm doesn't have an opening [at that level], the candidate would ultimately be rejected.”

“An employer wants to hire the right person, at the right time, who can grow into the role, develop and mature,” says Greer-King. “Employees generally want to be challenged; then, they tend to be happier and stay longer. At the heart of it, good isn’t necessarily good: a candidate can be wrong in areas other than skill and experience.”

‘Took my choice away’
Agile employers may also be able to recruit over-qualified workers and, by swiftly promoting them, pre-empt any feelings of boredom, says Shelley Crane, director of permanent placement services at recruiting firm Robert Half, based in London. That way, companies benefit from a worker’s experience, while keeping them motivated and engaged for the long haul.

“Someone ‘too good’ for the role will be only an asset to the business in the short term,” she says, “unless there are excellent internal progression opportunities.”

Right now, the hiring crisis implies employers can no longer afford to be quite so picky about over-qualified workers. Greer-King acknowledges that vetting for overly experienced candidates is harder when the battle for talent is so fierce.

Yet Crane says companies are more focused on retaining existing staff; overly skilled candidates are still being turned away. “In the current market, it can be costly and time-consuming to find someone new,” she says. “When over-qualified workers move on, the company is often back where it started.”

‘A catastrophic effect’
For workers keen to move, it can be tempting to deliberately downplay skills or omit experience from resumes, but Crane advises against this. Given a candidate’s career history will likely be discussed in a job interview, any dishonesty may be uncovered further down the recruitment process.

“It’s never a good idea to scale back your CV,” she says. She also warns workers more generally against applying for roles for which they are over-qualified, saying: “If someone applies for multiple roles below their skill level, and are rejected, it can have a catastrophic effect on their confidence.”

In the end, while patience and a determined job hunt can be rewarded, the reality is that some experienced candidates can find themselves stuck through no fault of their own. This can particularly be the case for senior employees, especially those who have been at one organisation for a long time. “They could be ingrained in another workplace culture,” says Greer-King. “That makes them less malleable.”

SOURCE: BBC
IMAGE SOURCE: PIXABAY

THE METRO BUSINESS

The Education That Matters: MSBM’s Guide to Thinking, Thriving, and Leading

How MSBM’s Executive Courses Prepare You to Out-think and Outperform the Competition

Insider Tips for Excelling in MSBM’s Online Courses

Strategies for Success: MSBM’s Business Management Insights

When Over-Qualified Workers Struggles To Find A Job

Top Stories

Nations are vying to join the BRICS group, according to South Africa, as Russia assumes leadership.

AI-Driven Business Transformation: A Project Management Perspective.

DUP has reached an agreement with the UK government to reinstate power-sharing in Northern Ireland.

Global Trade at Risk: The Implications of Red Sea Ship Attacks on Consumer Goods

Related Posts

5 Companies Where Employees Move Up the Ladder Fast

What Kind Of Worker Has Two Years Of Pandemic Made You? Here Are Three Types

As Small Businesses Recover From The Pandemic, They Face A New Obstacle: Finding Workers

Workers Faces A Tight Option, Covid Vaccination Or No Job